|
I’m a food writer and blogger and an advocate for local food, not a restaurant reviewer. But every now and then I cross into review territory. This is one of those times. If we’re going to drive almost 90 miles one-way for dinner, it’s because we’ve heard glowing reviews about a place or it’s a special occasion. Or both. Dean Lane Dining is a destination restaurant in the Finger Lakes, tucked away in the countryside between Seneca Lake and Keuka Lake (about 15 miles from Watkins Glen and 15 miles from Penn Yan). The descriptions “off the beaten path” and “middle of nowhere” come to mind and are 100% accurate. There was a moment when we wondered if the GPS had gone dead or we took a wrong turn on one of several gravel roads. But then there we were at our destination, a white farmhouse on a quiet country lane, with steps and a ramp leading to a dining room. This is where Michael and Lisa Dean live and have created a true hidden gem, noted for approachable fine dining with a focus on seasonal ingredients from area farms. The restaurant is open just three days a week (Friday, Saturday and Monday). The Deans work in tandem in the kitchen: Michael is the chef and Lisa is the pastry chef and dessert maker. They’re assisted by a sommelier and a team of servers who are passionate about food and wine. Weeks later, I’m still thinking about this dining adventure. Everything added up to a memorable meal. And I wasn’t even the one having a birthday. The vibe: Sleek and chic, yet comfortable. The main dining room seats about 40 people and features blonde, wood-grained tables for two, four and six, dressed simply with flatware and black and white linen napkins. It’s unpretentious yet upscale, the type of place that delivers a fresh fork or spoon with each course. The menu: Dean Lane offers a four-course, fixed-price menu ($65; $35 for an optional wine pairing) that changes twice a week: once on Monday and again for the Friday and Saturday service. Think Finger Lakes fresh, plus French influences: Courses generally include a seafood course or two, a red meat course and dessert, and each course has a vegetarian option. The spotlight on plant-based alternatives is refreshing, even though I do eat fish/seafood sometimes. And one of those occasions was the night we visited. The food: The first course of bay scallops Provencal, served with sauteed green and yellow squash, hummus and Romesco, a flavorful sauce made with tomatoes, red pepper, garlic, almonds and olive oil, was a winner right out of the gate. All the flavors and textures in this dish, from perfectly cooked vegetables and scallops to the savory accompaniments, combined to harmonize on the plate. We left not a speck. (The vegetarian option was silken tofu “scallops,’’ served the same way.) Other menu highlights included the second course of tuna tartare and red beet tartare. Small pieces of raw, sashimi grade tuna (or in my case, cubed red beets) shared the plate with avocado chunks dressed lightly in a punchy ginger soy sauce and garnished with strips of crispy wonton. The third course was even more adventurous, and an education in two things we’ve never had before: boulettes and jackfruit. Boulettes (French for meatball), can be made with any kind of meat or seafood. Dean Lane’s boulettes had a deep brown, crispy breading and were filled with pork, rice and seasonings and (in my case) jackfruit, rice and seasonings. Robert said his boulette contained more rice than pork and was subtle in flavor. Mine contained small pieces of chewy jackfruit, a tropical tree fruit with a meat-like texture. Both boulettes were served with a Cajun remoulade sauce and pickle slices that brightened the otherwise neutral boulettes. As for jackfruit, I’ve never tried it before and, if I’m being honest, I probably won’t go out of my way to try it again. But I appreciate the chef’s vegetarian options and his creativity with them. Lisa Dean’s desserts usually include one made with chocolate and one with fruit. Robert ordered the lemon posset, a creamy, tart custard served in a hollowed-out lemon half and garnished with two thin, chewy black sesame seed cookies. The blackberry chocolate cake was decadent: a rich square of dark chocolate cake layered with blackberry mascarpone and topped with blackberry buttercream icing. The wine: The commitment to local/regional sourcing extends to the restaurant’s all-Finger Lakes beverage list, which includes about 70 wines, plus beer, hard cider and spirits. That’s impressive. I've never seen so many Finger Lakes wines spotlighted on one list before. The optional wine pairing included four wines from Seneca Lake producers. We found it to be a great way to try things we might not otherwise try, like port (from nearby Lakewood Vineyards; a perfect partner for the dark chocolate cake) and the Vidal ice wine from Lamoreaux Landing Wine Cellars served with the lemon posset. All told, the four small pours are the equivalent of about a glass and a half of wine.
The service: Friendly and thoughtful. Attentive without being intrusive. When one of our servers learned that our wine course hadn’t been served with dessert, she brought a second lemon posset to sample along with the Vidal ice wine. The bill: Dinner for two, with the optional wine pairing, came to $200 before tax and tip. One last note: We’ll return to Dean Lane Dining and make an overnight or weekend of it. The distance isn’t a deterrent – there is plenty to do and see in the Finger Lakes. But it would be nice not to have to drive home to Syracuse after dinner (especially as the days get shorter). Dean Lane Dining is at 1100 Dean Lane, Dundee, about 87 miles southwest of Syracuse. Reservations are required. For more information, call 607-242-3149.
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Details
Like my articles and want to help out? This project is all about supporting local community, and that means these articles are created for free. If you'd like to contribute by buying me a cup of coffee to fuel this project, you can do so below:
Archives
August 2026
Categories |
RSS Feed